4th UPDATE — State Democrats, Republicans duel over U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding Obama health care plan

  • By The Associated Press
  • Thursday, June 28, 2012 4:31pm
  • News

By The Associated Press

EDITOR’S NOTE — For the latest national stories on the Supreme Court decision, click on “Nation/World” in the news toolbar, above. There is also video available on the www.peninsuladailynews.com home page.

OLYMPIA — Democrats in Washington state celebrated today’s U.S. Supreme Court decision upholding President Barack Obama’s health care overhaul, and key officials said the state is on track to continue implementing reforms.

In a 5-4 ruling, the court upheld virtually all of the law, including the contentious individual insurance requirement that was opposed by Washington state’s Republican Attorney General Rob McKenna, who joined in on the lawsuit against the wishes of Gov. Chris

Gregoire and other state Democrats.

Gregoire applauded the high court’s decision, saying “we firmly believed that this law was constitutional and would ultimately withstand legal challenge.”

“It is a historic decision that will allow Washington to continue to be a leader in this country in providing quality affordable health care,” she said at a news conference. “We still have a lot of work to do, but in Washington state, we’re ready for health care reform.”

Gregoire noted that Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, in her concurrence of the majority ruling, cited an amicus brief filed on the

Washington governor’s behalf that described the state’s failed attempt to reform health care in 1993.

“We went on our own, and we failed, because we didn’t have an individual mandate,” Gregoire said. “Without the individual mandate, we had a disaster in our state. We couldn’t go on our own. We needed national health care reform.”

While several reforms are currently in place in the state as a result of the new federal law, several benefits and programs won’t take effect until 2014, including an expansion of Medicaid for 328,000 low-income adults who don’t have children, and the ban preventing insurance companies from denying people coverage if they’re sick.

Online insurance exchanges are key to the federal health care law, and in March, Gregoire signed into law a bill setting rules for insurers preparing for the state’s online insurance exchange set to go live on Jan. 1, 2014.

Washington state Insurance Commissioner Mike Kreidler said that the months of uncertainty over what the ruling would be had been “one of those dark clouds that hung over our heads.”

Kreidler said state officials had been “proceeding at full speed” and called the ruling “vindication” of the work the state has already done.

“We feel a lot of relief,” he said.

Kreidler said that today’s ruling meant that “all the prep work wasn’t for naught, it was something that’s going to be critical for us to meet the timelines.”

The most recent U.S. Census Bureau numbers show that 927,000 people in the state are without health insurance, or 13.8 percent, though Kreidler’s office said their numbers show that more than one million, or 15 percent, don’t have insurance today.

McKenna, a Republican candidate for governor, had joined other GOP attorneys general in the federal health care lawsuit more than a year ago over the strong objections of Gregoire and Democratic lawmakers.

McKenna said that the court’s decision was a victory in one way because the mandate was called a tax. (See accompanying story.)

He said allowing the mandate under the Commerce Clause would have dramatically expanded the power of Congress to regulate what people can do, but he expressed concern about whether there were limits to how Congress could force people to take action by punishing them with taxes.

U.S. Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers, R-Spokane, said she was disappointed in the ruling but it will have “no impact on Congress’ continuing efforts to repeal the law.”

“In fact, we are more determined than ever to repeal it and replace it with something better,” she said in a written statement.

U.S. Rep. Jim McDermott, Democratic candidate for governor, called the Supreme Court’s upholding the health care law the biggest advance in social justice since Social Security 75 years ago.

McDermott told KOMO Radio in Seattle that everybody can look forward to having health insurance security in 2014.

U.S. Rep. Doc Hastings said he was disappointed in the Supreme Court’s ruling on the health care law.

Hastings, R-Pasco, said in a statement from Washington, D.C., the law will restrict health care options for individuals and add to the national debt.

Hastings said he will continue to support full repeal and a different approach to protect the patient-doctor relationship from government intrusion.

More in News

A street sweeper on I Street in Port Angeles cleans up the street along the curbs of all the debris that blew down during Tuesday evening’s storm. Thousands were without power at the peak of the storm. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Storm causes power outages, road closures

Smaller weather system may hit Friday

Port Angeles funds lodging tax requests

Sixteen applications to undergo review

Port Townsend’s Water Street sewer project gets funds

City council authorizes contracts; construction to start in January

Port of Port Angeles commissioners approve 2025 budget

Board OKs project that would treat seawater to make it less acidic

Two injured after truck collides with tree

Two people were injured when the truck in which… Continue reading

Power out for thousands in Clallam County

More than 11,000 electric meters were without power in… Continue reading

Shay-Lyn Szczepanik and her daughter Raelynn, 5, of Port Angeles are wind blown as they try to watch the wild waves at the base of Ediz Hook on Tuesday as the storm approaches. Many other weather watchers went to the spit to see and feel the winds. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Storm surge

Shay-Lyn Szczepanik and her daughter Raelynn, 5, of Port Angeles are wind… Continue reading

Fire Marshal and floodplain administrator Phil Cecere answers questions with deputy floodplain administrator Greg Ballard on Monday night in Brinnon. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Jefferson commissioners update flood code

More than 70 people attend hearing in Brinnon

PASD board accepts Brewer’s resignation

School officials highlight performance of Native American students

Port Angeles lifts Stage III water restrictions

The city of Port Angeles has lifted all of… Continue reading

Chipotle Mexican Grill opens today at 2021, Suite B, U.S. Highway 101 in Port Angeles. The fast food restaurant features freshly prepared burritos, burrito bowls, salads and tacos. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Chipotle opens in Port Angeles

Chipotle Mexican Grill opens today at 2021, Suite B, U.S. Highway 101… Continue reading

Agnes Kioko and Regina Mbaluku of Kenya and Bonita Piper, board president of Path From Poverty, right, meet with Sequim volunteers who cut and sell wood as a fundraiser. (Michael Dashiell/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Connection helps Kenyan women with opportunities, relationships

This effort, gifts from thousands of miles away, aren’t just… Continue reading