Can you trust caller ID?

  • By New York Times staff
  • Wednesday, November 23, 2011 12:01am
  • News

By New York Times staff

PLENTY OF PEOPLE rely on a quick glance at their phone’s caller ID screen to decide whether a call is worth picking up.

But as Matt Richtel reports in Wednesday’s New York Times — http://tinyurl.com/7dzfwjo — caller ID is not foolproof.

Regulators in many states have been hearing increasing numbers of complaints about spoofing: the name on the screen looks innocuous or even alarming, like “F.B.I.,” but answering the call reveals a telemarketer on the other end.

The Truth in Caller ID Act, passed last year — http://tinyurl.com/3l8ku2y — makes it illegal to send inaccurate caller ID information “with the intent to defraud, cause harm or wrongfully obtain anything of value.”

But technology, including Internet calling, has made it easier for callers to cloak themselves — and has made it harder to catch them.

The article has prompted a batch of responses from frustrated consumers.

On Twitter, @shirleykaiser says: “Ugh. This problem keeps worsening. Drives me nuts!!” And @Africana_Beauty writes, “Don’t pick up your house phone!!”

On DSL Reports, whose members like to chew on telecommunications issues — http://tinyurl.com/74zqqc3 — a discussion of the New York Times article has drawn a few comments from people who take this issue very seriously.

One said he had filed more than 30 complaints with the Federal Communications Commission about spoofed IDs, but “nothing happens.”

And a commenter using the name N9MD outlined his elaborate system for dealing with unwanted calls, using the blacklisting features offered by Internet calling services.

He said he gets many calls from collection bureaus, even though “I don’t owe anything to anybody . . . except my second-grade teacher Mrs. Johnson who lent me a nickel for lunch in November of 1949.”

More in News

Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News
About 700 participants took part in the 2025 People's March on Saturday in Port Townsend.The march went from the Quimper Mercantile parking lot to Pope Marine Park, a distance of 5 blocks. Formerly known as the Women's March, the name was changed this year to the People's March in order to be more inclusive.
People’s March in Port Townsend

About 700 participants took part in the 2025 People’s March on Saturday… Continue reading

Due to Helen Haller Elementary’s age, antiquated equipment, limited amenities, such as bathrooms, costs for renovation and many other factors, Sequim School District leaders are proposing a new elementary school as part of the Feb. 11 construction bond. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim school bond aims to address safety

Special election ballots mailed Wednesday

Clallam County Fire District 3 firefighters look to contain a fire in 2024. Calls for fires were down last year, but general calls for service were up from 2023. (Beau Sylte/Clallam County Fire District 3)
Fire districts in Sequim, Port Angeles see record numbers in 2024

Departments adding staff, focusing on connecting patients to resources

Rod Dirks enjoys affection from his 2-year-old daughter Maeli, who expresses confidence that doctors will heal her dad’s cancer. (Emily Matthiessen/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim man fighting rare form of cancer

Family faces uncertainty buoyed by community support

Ballots to be mailed Wednesday for special election

Four school districts put forward measures

Connor Cunningham of Port Townsend, an employee of the Port of Port Townsend, hangs a sign for new business owner Lori Hanemann of Port Townsend on Friday at her shop in what was a former mortgage office at Point Hudson Marina. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Shop sign

Connor Cunningham of Port Townsend, an employee of the Port of Port… Continue reading

Teenager receives heart transplant after 12-hour surgery

Additional surgery was expected to close chest

f
Readers give $108K in donations to Home Fund

Donations can be made for community grants this spring

Red Parsons, left, Kitty City assistant manager who will help run the Bark House, and Paul Stehr-Green, Olympic Peninsula Humane Society board president and acting executive director, stand near dog kennels discussing the changes they are making to the Bark House to ensure dogs are in a comfortable, sanitary environment when the facility reopens in February. (Emma Maple/Peninsula Daily News)
Humane Society officials plan to reopen Bark House

Facility, closed since last July, could be open by Valentine’s Day

Clallam EDC awarded $4.2M grant

Federal funding to support forest industry

Firm contacts 24 agencies for potential OMC partner

Hospital on timeline for decision in May