Darold Stenson at a court hearing earlier this summer. Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News

Darold Stenson at a court hearing earlier this summer. Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News

Evidence is released to defense in Darold Stenson’s murder retrial

PORT ANGELES — Evidence was ordered released for examination by Darold R. Stenson’s legal team Wednesday as preparations increased for the former Sequim-area resident’s double-aggravated-murder trial in Kitsap County beginning Sept. 16.

Clallam County Superior Court Judge S. Brooke Taylor said he wants Stenson, 60, transported Sept. 9 from the Clallam County jail, where he is being held without bail, to Kitsap County for Stenson’s estimated four- to six-week trial at the Kitsap County Courthouse in Port Orchard.

At Stenson’s next hearing at 10 a.m. Wednesday, Taylor will review the details of transporting Stenson, who is accused of killing his wife, Denise, and business partner, Frank Hoerner, in March 1993.

The state Supreme Court overturned Stenson’s 1994 conviction in May 2012.

A stay of execution was handed down in November 2008, eight days before his scheduled execution by lethal injection.

Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney Deb Kelly is seeking a sentence of life in prison at Stenson’s retrial.

Jury selection is slated for the week of Sept. 16, with testimony expected to begin Sept. 23.

A bearded, bald Stenson, who sat dressed in a faded red-and-black-striped inmate uniform, joked and smiled with his lawyers during a recess and did not make any statements to the court during the 1½-hour hearing.

Jury-selection questionnaires

Taylor said Wednesday he has not yet received jury-selection questionnaires from Stenson’s defense team and wants the forms by the court hearing Wednesday.

The bodies of Stenson’s wife and Hoerner were found at Stenson’s 55 Kane Lane exotic bird farm, which included a two-story house.

Hoerner, 33, was found dead and fully clothed in a first-floor bedroom of Stenson’s home, while Denise Stenson, 29, was found naked and bloodied in the upstairs master bedroom, according to court records.

Both had been shot in the head. Denise Stenson died the following day.

The Stensons’ children were in the home at the time of the shootings, according to court records.

A .357-caliber revolver was found next to Hoerner’s outstretched hand, according to court records.

Stenson claimed Hoerner had shot his wife and committed suicide.

But a police investigation showed Denise Stenson was shot first, then Hoerner was beaten and shot, according to court records.

Taylor released evidence for examination by crime-scene expert Kay Sweeney, a blood-spatter scientist who has become Stenson’s defense team’s crime-scene evaluator.

File cabinets, clothing

Evidence released by Taylor includes three file cabinets with documents.

It also includes Hoerner’s and Darold Stenson’s clothing, a .357-caliber revolver, bullets and bullet casings, a .22-caliber rifle, a portion of a headboard, gunshot residue from Hoerner’s hands and fingernail clippings removed from Denise Stenson.

“Many of the items they have demanded make no sense,” Kelly told Taylor, comparing the request to spinning a wheel and throwing darts at it.

“What on God’s green Earth is looking at fingernail clippings going to tell them?”

There was no evidence of a struggle, Kelly said, adding that the evidence showed that Denise Stenson was shot while sleeping in bed.

Sweeney was approved as a crime scene expert for Stenson on Aug. 16.

The time of the request for evidence and to expand Sweeney’s role “was made, frankly, for a tactical advantage,” Kelly said, adding that Stenson’s lawyer Roger Hunko of Port Orchard had said he was ready for trial in June.

Taylor said that with about 3½ weeks to go before trial, he shared some of Kelly’s concerns and noted Stenson’s defense team wanted a “truckload of material.”

Stenson’s lawyer Sherilyn Peterson of Seattle said Stenson’s lawyers “have learned a lot more in our investigation of this case” since earlier this summer.

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5060, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Cities, counties approve tax hikes

State law allows annual 1 percent increase

Health officer: Respiratory illnesses low on Peninsula

Berry says cases are beginning to rise regionally

A puppy named Captain Kirk is getting ready for adoption by Welfare for Animals Guild after it was rescued near Kirk Road. An unsecured makeshift kennel fell out of a truck on U.S. Highway 101 last month and was struck by another vehicle. (Welfare for Animals Guild)
Puppy rescued from wreck to be adopted

A puppy named Captain Kirk is about to boldly go… Continue reading

Festival of Trees raises record $231,000

The 34th annual Festival of Trees, produced by the… Continue reading

Man flown to hospital after single-car collision

A 67-year-old man was flown to an Everett hospital after… Continue reading

Lost Mountain Station 36 at 40 Texas Valley Road recently sold to a neighbor after Clallam County Fire District 3 was unable to recruit volunteers to staff the station. Its proceeds will go toward future construction of a new Carlsborg Station 33. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group file)
District sells one fire station

Commissioners approve 2025 budget

Clallam County Master Gardener Gordon Clark cuts leaves off Isobel Johnston’s agave plant that she had been growing for 28-plus years. She specifically requested Master Gardeners help her remove the plant while keeping at least one for years to come. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Master Gardeners help remove agave plant on Fifth Avenue

Several baby plants uncovered below large leaves

Harvey Hochstetter tosses a box of food to Cameron Needham to stack with fellow volunteers like Bill Needham, right, for the Sequim Food Bank’s Holiday Meal Bag Distribution event. Cameron, his father Ty and grandfather Bill were three generations helping the program. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim Thanksgiving program helps 1,200 families

About 30 volunteers pack holiday boxes

Security exercise set at Indian Island

Naval Magazine Indian Island will conduct a security training… Continue reading

Operations scheduled at Bentinck range this week

Training at the land-based demolition range on Bentinck Island… Continue reading

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading