Ex-Clallam commissioner hopeful files bias complaint

Dale Holiday

Dale Holiday

PORT ANGELES — Dale Holiday, a former candidate for Clallam County commissioner and a current county employee, has filed a racial and sex discrimination complaint against the county.

Her charge of discrimination was filed March 29 with the Washington Human Rights Commission and the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

Holiday, an African-American, said in the complaint that the discrimination was based on her race and gender and occurred in retaliation for her “protests of race discrimination.”

Holiday, 58, did not respond to two email requests for comment.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Holiday, who works in the county Department of Health and Human Services, and the county have agreed to mediate the dispute in a session that has yet to be scheduled but could result in a monetary settlement for Holiday or in a lawsuit if mediation does not work, Administrator Jim Jones said Tuesday.

Jones said Holiday had made the offer for the complaint to be mediated.

“We categorically deny all the accusations and intend to defend ourselves in whichever venue we need to go,” Jones said.

“If you can come to a settlement, it’s in the interest of everybody.

“It’s less expensive to go through than going to court.”

Holiday, the full-time grant coordinator for Health and Human Services, is paid $24.98 an hour, or $51,958 annually, said county Human Resources Department Director Rich Sill.

Holiday unsuccessfully ran as a Democrat in the primary election for county commissioner in August 2012 in a general election race that was won by incumbent Mike Chapman, an independent.

Holiday is the wife of Port Angeles City Councilman Max Mania, who is not seeking re-election in the Nov. 5 general election.

A copy of the complaint was obtained by the Peninsula Daily News.

Text of complaint

Here’s a complete text of the complaint:

“Since mid-2012, I have been subjected to lower-graded performance evaluations than those I previously earned; and to a warning letter dated Oct. 26, 2012; and I was placed on a performance improvement plan; and I am required to make a weekly task list although other employees only are required to make a monthly task list; and I was denied approval to attend the Montana Summer Institute for 2013.

“I believe that these actions are based on my race, black; and are in retaliation for my protests of race discrimination; and are based on my sex, female; in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended.”

Holiday worked for the county Department of Community Development from June 2007 to December 2010, Sill said.

She has worked at Health and Human Services since December 2010.

Holiday relayed concerns about discrimination verbally to Jones earlier this year, he said.

“She complained in a meeting with me that she has been the victim of racial discrimination many times throughout her life and including, previous to this instance, in the county,” Jones said.

Jones said it was the first time he learned that Holiday believed she was being discriminated against at her job.

“When she came to me, it was on the specific issues of how she believed she was being treated unfairly because of her supervisors’ disapproval of the quality of her work,” Jones said.

She told Jones that the performance improvement plan was imposed because of her race and gender, and was in retaliation for her protesting racial discrimination against her, Jones said.

After talking with Holiday’s supervisors and the county Human Resources Department, Jones told Holiday on March 22 — a week before Holiday filed the complaint — that he saw no evidence of discrimination, he said.

“I told her if I found instances of it, I would not tolerate it, and the county would not tolerate it,” Jones said.

EEOC next step

Even if the county won a lawsuit over the complaint in court, the county could not collect damages to recover attorney fees, he said.

“The next step is to have a hearing with the EEOC officer,” he said.

“We are just preparing all the paperwork for that.”

A state Insurance Risk Pool lawyer is handling the case at no cost to the county, Jones said.

That lawyer will be paid from the county’s $100,000 insurance deductible once the mediation process begins, he said.

There are no other current discrimination complaints that have been filed against the county, and “three or four” have been settled with monetary settlements since mid-2006, when Jones became county administrator, he said.

“[Holiday] hasn’t lost any work or anything,” Jones said.

“At this point, if it goes to court, she could make a claim for attorney fees, pain and suffering, who knows.”

Rudy Hurtado, a program analyst with the EEOC’s Seattle field office, said about 80 percent of EEOC charges of discrimination that go to mediation are resolved without proceeding to court.

“Is there some sort of monetary settlement involved?

“Generally there is, but not always,” Hurtado said.

The goal is to make the person “whole” based on what the person lost as a result of the discrimination, he added.

“It’s a matter of making things right.”

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5060, or at paul.gottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Holly Hildreth of Port Townsend, center, orders a latte for the last time at the Guardhouse, a cafe at Fort Worden State Park, on Wednesday. At noon the popular cafe was to close permanently, leaving an empty space for food, drinks and restroom facilities in the park. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Fort Worden Hospitality closes business operations

Organization faced with ‘legal limbo’ because lease was rejected

Clallam fire districts providing automatic support

Mutual aid helps address personnel holes

Port Angeles school board to meet with hiring agency

The Port Angeles School District board of directors will… Continue reading

Clallam County to host meeting to develop animal disaster plan

The Clallam County Sheriff’s Office’s Emergency Management division will… Continue reading

The Western Harbor Study Area includes Port Angeles Harbor, the Port of Port Angeles and Ediz Hook. (State Department of Ecology)
Comment period to open on Port Angeles Harbor cleanup

The state Department of Ecology will open a public… Continue reading

C.J. Conrad and Chris Orr of A&R Solar take solar panels from a lift on top of the Port Angeles Senior and Community Center on Peabody Street to be installed on the roof. The 117 panels are mostly made of silicone and will provide electrical power to the center. The crew members are each tied in with ropes to prevent any problems on the slippery slanted roof. The panels are 42 inches by 62 inches and weigh about 16 pounds. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Solar installation

C.J. Conrad and Chris Orr of A&R Solar take solar panels from… Continue reading

Port Townsend Food Co-op board president resigns

Rowe cites unresolved tensions, calls for change

Recompete projects aim to close gap for workers in prime age

Goals include reducing barriers, creating up to 1,300 jobs

Carrie Heaton.
Governor appoints Heaton to PC trustees

Five-member board governs college’s policy, strategic planning

Finalists named for Port Angeles community awards

The Port Angeles Chamber of Commerce will announce the… Continue reading

Fort Worden Hospitality ceasing operations

No longer viable amid PDA financial and legal challenges

You're browsing in private mode.
Please sign in or subscribe to continue reading articles in this mode.

Peninsula Daily News relies on subscription revenue to provide local content for our readers.

Subscribe

Already a subscriber? Please sign in