FBI gets about 100 phone calls on serial murderer; no ties to Peninsula missing persons suspected

Israel Keyes

Israel Keyes

PORT ANGELES — The FBI has received about 100 phone calls since issuing an Aug. 3 plea for information about the late serial murderer Israel Keyes, who lived in Neah Bay from 2001 to 2007.

Special Agent Jolene Goeden of Anchorage, who is leading the investigation into the identities of those murdered by Keyes, said this week that none of the calls the FBI has received since mid-August connected Keyes to missing persons in Clallam or Jefferson counties.

But the FBI did receive tips on missing persons elsewhere in the Pacific Northwest.

Agents are investigating those, Goeden said.

“They are cases we’re not able to rule him out of, but we can’t rule him into, either,” Goeden said.

“We did get phone calls at times from people who knew him, who would have been from that area, I’m assuming, from Port Angeles and Neah Bay, just to give information.

“The majority of phone calls were from people who knew him and interacted with him, who would give information about the types of things he did, activity he was involved in, those types of things.”

Keyes has been linked to 11 killings between 2001 and 2012, including five while living in Neah Bay.

In 2012, at age 34, he committed suicide in an Anchorage jail while awaiting trial in the rape and murder of 18-year-old Samantha Koenig, a barista abducted from an Anchorage coffee stand.

He had confessed to FBI agents to killing Koenig and at least seven others in a countrywide crime spree, including two between 2005 and 2006, disposing of at least one of the bodies by dumping it from a boat in Lake Crescent, west of Port Angeles.

Keyes had told investigators in Alaska that he killed four people in Washington, including a couple in the state, between 2001 and 2005.

None of Keyes’ victims appears to have lived in Clallam or Jefferson counties, Clallam County Undersheriff Ron Peregrin and Jefferson County Sheriff’s Detective Brett Anglin said Tuesday.

Anglin said the Jefferson County Sheriff’s Office is investigating a report of a missing person, Delmar Sample, 53, of Onalaska, who was last seen in the Lake Quinault area in March 2005.

“There’s nothing that links him to Israel Keyes at this point,” Anglin said.

Goeden said two agents in the FBI’s Seattle office have been assigned to the case to investigate any leads in Washington state.

“The FBI does not typically release investigative details, like tips or leads,” Ayn Sandalo Dietrich, a spokeswoman for the agency’s Seattle office, said Tuesday in an email.

“The only thing I’d want to reiterate with your readers is that the FBI continues to solicit the public’s help in providing any information that could lead us to other victims of Israel Keyes.”

Anyone with information about Keyes or his possible victims should call 800-225-5324, or 800-CALL-FBI.

In November, three months after the FBI issued its call for information, the agency identified a possible adult victim, Debra Feldman of Hackensack, N.J., whose body was never recovered.

In its Nov. 13 press release on Feldman, the FBI said Keyes’ victims, who were both male and female, ranged from their late teens to the elderly.

Keyes told investigators he murdered his victims in fewer than 10 states but did not disclose all the locations or the victims’ identities.

“Keyes described significant planning and preparation for his murders, reflecting a meticulous and organized approach to his crimes,” the release said.

Keyes also left “murder kits” in various locations around the country that contained, among other items, weapons and cash, Goeden said.

“Unfortunately, Keyes was really good at what he did.

“He was not someone who left a lot of evidence behind.

“We have a subject and we are trying to find the victims, so it is a little nontraditional in terms of how cases are being worked.

“We are trying to find the evidence.”

Makah tribal members told Peninsula Daily News in August that Keyes was a model citizen in Neah Bay, working for the tribe, doing landscaping and putting out plants and flowers in the town.

A hiker, Keyes obtained overnight Olympic National Park backcountry permits.

He was known to look for victims in remote areas, authorities said.

When Keyes left Neah Bay he moved to Alaska, a location from which he traveled extensively.

“It is not unlikely that in some cases, Keyes abducted a victim from one state, transported the victim to another state, where he or she was murdered, and potentially drove the victim to a third state to dispose of the body,” the FBI said in its Nov. 13 statement.

A general contractor, Keyes admitted to burglarizing 20 to 30 homes across the country and discussed, with investigators, committing arson to cover up a homicide.

“He was a very successful contractor,” Goeden said.

“We know he also had done several bank robberies.

“Some of his travel was funded by that as well.”

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5060, or at pgottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Increased police presence expected at Port Angeles High School on Friday

An increased police presence is expected at Port Angeles… Continue reading

Clallam County Superior Court Judge Elizabeth Stanley is sworn in by Judge Simon Barnhart on Thursday at the Clallam County Courthouse. Stanley, elected in November to Position 1, takes the role left by Judge Lauren Erickson, who retired. Barnhart and Judge Brent Basden also were elected in November. All three ran unopposed. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Judge sworn in

Clallam County Superior Court Judge Elizabeth Stanley is sworn in by Judge… Continue reading

Clallam trending toward more blue

Most precincts supported Harris in 2024

Landon Smith, 19, is waiting for a heart transplant at Children’s Hospital of Seattle. (Michelle Smith)
Teenager awaits heart transplant in Seattle

Being in the hospital increases his chances, mom says

Port, Lower Elwha approve agreement

Land exchange contains three stormwater ponds for infrastructure

Clallam County lodging tax funds awarded

$1.39 million to be provided to four organizations

Forks DSHS outstation updates service hours

The state Department of Social and Health Services has announced… Continue reading

A 65-foot-long historic tug rests in the Port of Port Townsend Boat Haven Marina’s 300-ton marine lift as workers use pressure washers to blast years of barnacles and other marine life off the hull. The tug was built for the U.S. Army at Peterson SB in Tacoma in 1944. Originally designated TP-133, it is currently named Island Champion after going through several owners since the army sold it in 1947. It is now owned by Debbie Wright of Everett, who uses it as a liveaboard. The all-wood tug is the last of its kind and could possibly be entered in the 2025 Wooden Boat Festival.(Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Wooden wonder

A 65-foot-long historic tug rests in the Port of Port Townsend Boat… Continue reading

Mark Nichols.
Petition filed in murder case

Clallam asks appeals court to reconsider

A 35-year-old man was taken by Life Flight Network to Harborview Medical Center following a Coast Guard rescue on Monday. (U.S. Coast Guard Air Station Port Angeles via Facebook)
Injured man rescued from remote Hoh Valley

Location requires precision 180-foot hoist

Kevin Russell, right, with his wife Niamh Prossor, after Russell was inducted into the Building Industry Association of Washington’s Hall of Fame in November.
Building association’s priorities advocate for housing

Port Angeles contractor inducted into BIAW hall of fame

Crew members from the USS Pomfret, including Lt. Jimmy Carter, who would go on to become the 39th president of the United States, visit the Elks Lodge in Port Angeles in October 1949. (Beegee Capos)
Former President Carter once visited Port Angeles

Former mayor recalls memories of Jimmy Carter