Four cases dropped in wake of Sheriff’s Department investigations

PORT ANGELES — The legal fallout from two investigations into Clallam County sheriff’s officers continues to spill over, disrupting court cases and dealing the department a public relations black eye.

So far, three Superior Court cases and one District Court case have been dismissed because of the involvement of either former Sgt. Dave Fontenot or Deputy Dwane Hayden.

Prosecutors and defense attorneys are combing through their cases and bracing for more dismissals.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney Deborah Kelly said her office is going through case files, searching for those scheduled for trial soon and acknowledged there may be more dismissals to come.

“I’m sure there are more that these two have been involved in over the past year,” she said.

All the dismissed charges could be refiled, but Kelly said she wouldn’t know if they will be refiled until after the investigations are completed.

Clallam Public Defenders Executive Director Harry Gasnick said his attorneys are also going through their cases looking for instances where Fontenot was involved in obtaining search warrants and handling evidence.

“We’ll do the same thing with Hayden,” Gasnick said.

Evidence mismanagement

Allegations against Fontenot include mismanagement of evidence, according to statements from the Sheriff’s Department and court documents.

Fontenot was placed on paid administrative leave Sept. 16 and he resigned Sept. 22.

Hayden was placed on paid administrative leave Oct. 10.

Sheriff Joe Martin said Thursday that the outside investigation into Fontenot has been completed and he is awaiting the results.

The investigation into Hayden is ongoing.

No criminal conduct has been alleged in either case, but Martin said that the longer the investigations are drawn out the more harm that is done to the department’s reputation.

“I’m a firm believer in timely and accurate investigations and bringing any situation to fruition as soon as possible,” Martin said.

“Unfortunately, this process has gone on for awhile, longer than I would like to see happen.”

He has instructed staff to not speculate on the investigations and to “move on the things we do so well.”

More in News

A portion of the crowd at the Hands Off rally, which started at the intersection of Laurel and First Street. An estimated 800 to 1,000 people attended in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/For Peninsula Daily News)
Hands Off! protests on Peninsula

A portion of the crowd at the Hands Off rally, which started… Continue reading

Kathy Cruz/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Susan Fisch, standing, chair of the Clallam County Charter Review Commission, addresses a crowd of residents who packed the meeting room at KSQM FM (91.5) last month for the first of several town hall events. Speakers were allowed up to three minutes to share their views about issues related to the charter that they consider most important.
Charter meeting draws crowd

Open house set tonight in Joyce

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Margo Karler of Port Townsend looks up at the plaster covers protecting a tusk that was found by hikers on the beach near the Point Wilson lighthouse in March. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Fossil found in sandstone bluff at Fort Worden

State Parks, Burke museum developing plan for preservation

Ian’s Ride receives volunteer service award

Ian’s Ride has received a Washington State Volunteer Service Award… Continue reading

Boating coach Eric Lesch, at a whiteboard, explains sailing techniques to a youth sailboat class. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Teenagers learning boating skills through program

Nonprofit funded by grants, agencies and donations

Land trust successful with campaign fund

Public access expected to open this year

Mark Hodgson.
Hodgson plans to run for Port Angeles City Council

Schromen-Wawrin, who currently holds seat, won’t run again

Pet vaccination clinic set for Saturday in Port Townsend

Pet Helpers of Port Townsend will conduct a pet… Continue reading