Gregoire proposes sobriety checkpoints for drivers

  • By David Ammons, The Associated Press
  • Monday, January 7, 2008 9:00pm
  • News

By David Ammons, The Associated Press

OLYMPIA — Gov. Chris Gregoire on Monday proposed “sobriety checkpoints” in selected high-accident areas as part of the state’s continuing clampdown on drunken driving.

The proposal drew immediate support from law enforcement and citizen activists, but civil libertarians vowed a battle in the Legislature and in the courts.

The American Civil Liberties Union said the plan would violate the state’s strong protections against “suspicionless” searches.

Spokesman Doug Honig said the state Supreme Court threw out Seattle’s checkpoints near 20 years ago and that the ban on DUI roadblocks is long-settled.

Gregoire spokesman Aaron Toso said the plan wouldn’t violate the court’s ruling.

“The ban is against searches without the authority of law. This proposal provides legal authority if the warrant is issued by a Superior Court judge to conduct these checks,” he said.

The governor’s plan will be sponsored by the House Judiciary Committee chairwoman, Rep. Pat Lantz, D-Gig Harbor, a lawyer.

The Senate judiciary chairman, Adam Kline, D-Seattle, has long worked on drunken driving legislation.

The proposal would require law enforcement to get a warrant from the local Superior Court after giving the judge a plan for a specific location and time period. The checkpoints would be in areas that are known for frequent alcohol and drug-related collisions.

The proposed legislation would require the judge to approve the warrant if the plan “advances the jurisdiction’s interest in reducing impaired driving, taking into account potential arrests under the program and the program’s deterrent effect.”

The measure says checkpoints should “minimize intrusions into the privacy rights of drivers and vehicle occupants.”

The bill says all vehicles except for emergency vehicles would have to stop at each checkpoint. A person who failed to stop could be prosecuted for a gross misdemeanor. That could carry a maximum penalty of a year in jail and $5,000 fine.

The plan calls for advance notice to the public and a report back to the court on how the checkpoint project worked.

“Sobriety checkpoints will be an important tool for law enforcement to catch drunk drivers and will help keep families safer when they are on the road,” Gregoire said in comments released by her office.

“Let’s hope these checkpoints will keep would-be drunk drivers from even getting behind the wheel and take those who make the bad decision to drink and drive off the road.”

Gregoire announced her proposal at Meadowdale High School in Lynnwood, north of Seattle. She was joined by State Patrol Chief John Batiste, Snohomish County Sheriff John Lovick and community leaders.

She planned a demonstration of how a checkpoint would work and met with Students Against Destructive Decisions.

“If approved, this legislation will save lives by letting law enforcement operate sobriety checkpoints in the areas most likely to have impaired drivers,” Batiste said. “We will go where the impaired drivers go, with the goal of getting them off the road.”

Gregoire was joined by Lisa McCollum, whose mother-in-law, Jenny, died in a car crash caused by a drunken driver.

“I am a witness to the painfully permanent impact that drinking and driving can have on our families,” McCollum said, endorsing the governor’s plan.

Lantz, the House sponsor, said Washington is one of just 11 states that does not use sobriety checkpoints to catch drunken drivers.

“Law enforcement needs every tool available to prevent the tragedies these offenders cause,” she said.

But Honig said there are grave constitutional questions that Gregoire’s plan doesn’t satisfy.

A landmark opinion by the state high court in 1988 said the state constitution doesn’t permit motorists to be routinely stopped without suspicion or probable cause to believe the individual is doing something wrong.

The U.S. Supreme Court has approved checkpoints, such as the approach used in Michigan, but Washington has stronger privacy protections against suspicionless search-and-seizure, Honig said.

The state allows “emphasis patrols” where law enforcement concentrates manpower in high-accident areas and pulls over people when their vehicles are weaving or showing other obvious signs of the driver being impaired, he said.

“Certainly drunken driving is a serious concern and there are effective law enforcement programs for dealing with it that are legal,” he said in an interview. “We don’t have to interfere with individual rights. Privacy means the government doesn’t intrude on you and your private affairs.”

He said calling it an “administrative” checkpoint doesn’t change the fact that suspicionless searches are illegal and that any warrants authorizing DUI stops must follow the rules for all criminal search warrants.

More in News

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200 block of West 10th street in Port Angeles. Halloween events are scheduled today throughout the North Olympic Peninsula. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Ghostly visions

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles awarded $9.4M in funds

Will help move toward zero-emission goals

Potential defense workload changes could have ripple effects

Clallam, Jefferson counties brace for decision, expected in January

Leaders discuss rural reproductive health

Policy, funding and workforce shortages considered

There were no serious injuries after a two-car collision pushed a Chevrolet pickup truck into the corner of the Emporium building at the corner of Eighth and Cherry streets in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Two-car collision pushes truck into building

A Chevrolet pickup truck collided with a building following… Continue reading

Two Totem Poles were missing from The Quileute Tribe’s 101 Building in Forks.
Sheriff’s office seeking information about missing totem poles

The Clallam County Sheriff’s Office is looking for information about… Continue reading

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge on Tuesday. The forecast for the rest of the week calls for high temperatures hovering about 50 degrees with a chance of showers and overnight lows in the low 40s. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Snowy peaks over Port Angeles

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge… Continue reading

Clallam County, Flaura’s Acres establish agreement

Utility Local Improvement District may be formed

Ecology updates on eight Port Angeles cleanup sites

Sites not of particular worry, state spokesperson says

Deputy Mayor Rachel Anderson thanks Sequim police officer Mark Poole with a proclamation of his Lifesaving Award on Oct. 14 for preventing a man from jumping from the River Road bypass in August. (John Southard)
Sequim police officer honored with Lifesaving Award

Sequim Police Officer Mark Poole was awarded a 2024 Lifesaving… Continue reading

PASD is hopeful about its bond, levy

Safety, security at buildings, officials say

Federal case dismissed against Jefferson County

Prosecutor says office ‘vindicated’ by decision