Inmate suit against Clallam Bay corrections officers to go to trial

Kyle Lee Payment required eight stitches after using a razor that he alleges was provided to him by corrections officers to cut his wrists and arms during a 2013 suicide attempt. Washington Department of Corrections

Kyle Lee Payment required eight stitches after using a razor that he alleges was provided to him by corrections officers to cut his wrists and arms during a 2013 suicide attempt. Washington Department of Corrections

A federal judge has ordered a trial in a lawsuit filed by a former Clallam Bay Corrections Center inmate alleging two corrections officers gave him a shaving razor after he threatened to kill himself.

Kyle L. Payment, 28, said in the lawsuit filed in June 2013 that he used the razor, given to him after he was escorted to a shower, and cut himself along his arm, resulting in the need for eight stitches.

Payment, who is representing himself in the case, said his rights were violated because the corrections officers deliberately failed to protect him from himself.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

Payment said Officers Randy Simonsen and Steven Weed gave him the razor and a shower kit, which also included a towel and soap, after he had pressed the emergency call button in his cell because he was having suicidal thoughts Feb. 20, 2013.

He said he asked whether he was going to get a razor, to which Weed replied, “Absolutely.”

Payment also claimed he heard Weed say to Simonsen, “What, you think I want to put up with him for the next 30 years?”

Payment says in the suit that Weed handed him the razor, saying, “Here, you are going to need this — that is, if you are really serious,” and walked away.

In his ruling filed July 21, U.S. District Judge Ronald Leighton dismissed several other defendants in the lawsuit, including the superintendent of the Clallam Bay Corrections Center, but said the claims against Simonsen and Weed will stand.

Leighton agreed with U.S. District Judge J. Richard Creatura’s recommendation that material issues of fact remain regarding whether Simonsen and Weed inferred Payment was a danger to himself and ignored the risk in allowing Payment to have the razor.

In a joint status report, Payment and the state Attorney General’s Office agreed that the case would be ready for trial Dec. 1. No date has been set, according to court records.

Payment now is in the Stafford Creek Corrections Center in Aberdeen.

He has been there since August 2013 after he was transferred from Clallam Bay, Department of Corrections spokeswoman Norah West said Thursday.

In a motion to dismiss the case, Assistant State Attorney General Eric Miller argued that “this was no suicide attempt.”

Miller argued that Payment took advantage of a “chaotic situation” during the removal of an unruly inmate from his cell to call for help and said Payment was upset he had lost his recreation time.

Payment was being kept in the Intensive Management Unit — in which inmates that pose threats to themselves, others or staff are kept separate from the corrections center’s general population — because of a history of assaults against staff, Miller wrote.

For security reasons, inmates in the Intensive Management Unit were not taken to the showers or to recreation time while corrections officers dealt with the other inmate, Miller wrote.

Miller said it was a miscommunication among staff members that allowed Payment to be issued a razor after he had said he was suicidal.

Prison policy prevents inmates considered violent or suicidal from having razors or other items that could be used to hurt themselves or others, Miller wrote, though Payment was not specifically restricted from having a shaving razor at the time of the incident.

Miller wrote that medical personnel responded “immediately” to Payment after he made what Miller called “superficial” cuts on his arm.

Miller wrote that Payment began his current sentence in 2004 for assault and “has remained incarcerated because of additional convictions for multiple assaults against staff.”

“[Payment] has spent the majority of his sentence in Intensive Management Units because of his assaultive behavior,” Miller wrote.

In the motion to dismiss, Miller also listed multiple instances of Payment calling officers to his cell for false emergencies and claiming to be suicidal when he was upset with staff or wanted food or other items.

_________

Reporter Jeremy Schwartz can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5074, or at jschwartz@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

A pair of wind surfers take off from the breakwater at Port Townsend Marina in an apparent race across the bay on Tuesday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Catching the wind

A pair of wind surfers take off from the breakwater at Port… Continue reading

Clallam County Economic Development Council Director of Operations Lorie Fazio, left, and Executive Director Colleen McAleer stand with Michael Cade, executive director of Thurston EDC who presented the WEDA’s 2025 Innovation in Economic Development award. The EDC received the award last month in recognition of its Clallam Forest Product Innovation Program.
Clallam EDC wins state innovation award

Forest innovation program intended to revitalize industry

Port Townsend library to show Willa Cather documentary

Free novels, dramatic reading Thursday at 5:30

Jefferson sets short-term rental rules

County establishes 4 percent cap, one rental per operator

When former deputy and pilot John L. Strachan told his wife Jennie that his final wish was for his ashes to be sent into space, she wondered if he was kidding. After all, could such a thing even be done? Turns out, it can — and Jennie is making it happen. (Jennie Strachan)
When former deputy and pilot John L. Strachan told his wife Jennie that his final wish was for his ashes to be sent into space, she wondered if he was kidding. After all, could such a thing even be done? Turns out, it can — and Jennie is making it happen. (Jennie Strachan)
Former deputy’s ashes to be sent into space

Widow of John Strachan to fulfill his dream

Port OKs Citizen Air lease

Company purchasing Rite Bros. Aviation

Rebates offered for e-bikes through April 23

The state Department of Transportation will accept applications for e-bike… Continue reading

Jefferson County Public Health names heroes

Jefferson County Public Health has announced its 2025 Public… Continue reading

Man transported to hospital after log truck goes into ditch

A log truck driver was transported to Forks Community Hospital… Continue reading

Heath Wade, 5, leads the goat parade to open the 37th annual Port Townsend Farmers Market on Saturday in the uptown neighborhood. Behind are goat wranglers Lindsey Kotzebue and Amber Langley of Port Townsend. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Market opens

Heath Wade, 5, leads the goat parade to open the 37th annual… Continue reading

Kelly Kidwell, a local business owner and property developer, is purchasing Rite Bros. with the intention of building a long-term sustainable business that will expand aviation access in the area. Citizen Air, based at William R. Fairchild International Airport, will offer charter flights and fractional aircraft ownership. The possibility of scheduled flights could be in the distant future. Kidwell is shown with his Poodle-Bernese mountain dog, Porter. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Citizen Air aims to expand access

New Rite Bros. owner planning for growth

Health officer: Disease numbers low, but cuts affecting programs

Additional measles case located in Washington state