Click map to enlarge (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Click map to enlarge (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)

Makah whale hunting permit effort, a long-fought controversy, would see debate resume

NEAH BAY — Makah whale hunters plied the Pacific Ocean for centuries.

It may seem like they’ve hoped that long to return to the high-seas chase.

It’s actually been only since 1991 that the tribe has sought to kill whales again under their 1855 Treaty of Neah Bay, but — except for one legal hunt in May 1999 and a botched rogue kill in September 2007 — they’ve been beached by the federal Marine Mammal Protection Act.

That act is what anti-whaler Margaret Owens of Joyce calls “the whales’ treaty with the government,” and she is as steadfast in her opposition to whaling as the tribe is determined to resume it.

The Makah’s continuing effort reached its latest point Friday with the release of a new draft environmental impact statement by the National Marine Fisheries Service that offers six alternatives.

Among them is a “no action” alternative, which would mean no hunting of gray whales off the Makah reservation.

That option is the choice of pro-whale activists led by Owens and her husband, Chuck, whose Peninsula Citizens for the Protection of Whales has fought the tribe on picket lines and in court for 16 years.

As for the other choices, which include “taking” as many as five whales a year, “I’m sure they are all going to be very distasteful,” she said.

Neither Owens nor Makah tribal officials said they could comment on specifics of the newly released statement.

Nonetheless, just getting this far was a victory for the Makah.

“We are a patient people,” said Meredith Parker, tribal general manager.

“We feel secure in knowing our past and its link to the future. Whaling is something that is a large factor in our culture, then and today.”

Makah Tribal Chairman Timothy J. Greene Sr. echoed Parker:

“Our treaty right to whaling is important to us spiritually and culturally.”

Resuming hunting whales looks unlikely, however, if the Owenses and their anti-whaling allies convince the fisheries service — and, perhaps later, federal courts — to continue to ban whaling as key to allowing whales to flourish.

Throughout the controversy, the Makah and other tribes have championed the treaty right to whaling as a keystone of tribal sovereignty.

Makah whalers once stood atop the tribe’s society, with the highest honors going to harpooners and men who dove from cedar canoes into the Pacific to sew shut the captured whales’ mouths so they wouldn’t sink.

As for current efforts, “the tribe is happy we’re able to reach a point where we may actually return to our treaty right to whale,” Greene said.

But Margaret Owens’ agenda will remain to save the whales.

“Our group’s position has remained unchanged since 1998,” she said. “We feel it is our honor to continue to speak for the great gray whales in the hope that they will be allowed to live safe and peaceful lives amongst us, and continue to fill us with awe and joy.”

________

Reporter James Casey can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 5074, or at jcasey@peninsuladailynews.com

More in News

Election security measures in place

Fire suppressant just one example

Ruby Speer, 3, of Port Angeles receives a treat from KaraLee Monroe of Kindred Collective as part of Thursday’s Halloween festivities in downtown Port Angeles. Hundreds of youngsters and adults made their way door-to-door in search of candy and other treasures. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Trick or treat in Port Angeles

Ruby Speer, 3, of Port Angeles receives a treat from KaraLee Monroe… Continue reading

Karen Huber, sister of Nash Huber, the owner of Nash’s Organic Produce, stands by large crates that hold various seeds that Nash sells to farmers. She said she’s mitigated alleged violations and concerns from property owner, Washington Land Trust, but the longtime farmer faces eviction from the property if he doesn’t comply with ending his lease agreement that goes through 2032. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Washington Farmland Trust could evict Dungeness farmer

Nash Huber helped preserve Delta Farm in 1999

Amy Seidewand chair making. (Lacey Carnahan)
Port Townsend Woodworkers Show ready for the weekend

Event dedicated to memory of woodworking pillar

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200 block of West 10th street in Port Angeles. Halloween events are scheduled today throughout the North Olympic Peninsula. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Ghostly visions

Two ghosts dangle from a tree in the breeze in the 200… Continue reading

Port of Port Angeles awarded $9.4M in funds

Will help move toward zero-emission goals

Potential defense workload changes could have ripple effects

Clallam, Jefferson counties brace for decision, expected in January

Leaders discuss rural reproductive health

Policy, funding and workforce shortages considered

There were no serious injuries after a two-car collision pushed a Chevrolet pickup truck into the corner of the Emporium building at the corner of Eighth and Cherry streets in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Two-car collision pushes truck into building

A Chevrolet pickup truck collided with a building following… Continue reading

Two Totem Poles were missing from The Quileute Tribe’s 101 Building in Forks.
Sheriff’s office seeking information about missing totem poles

The Clallam County Sheriff’s Office is looking for information about… Continue reading

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge on Tuesday. The forecast for the rest of the week calls for high temperatures hovering about 50 degrees with a chance of showers and overnight lows in the low 40s. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Snowy peaks over Port Angeles

A recent snow is visible from Port Angeles on the Klahhane Ridge… Continue reading

Clallam County, Flaura’s Acres establish agreement

Utility Local Improvement District may be formed