Motion to dismiss Pierce’s double-murder charges extends to fourth day

PORT ORCHARD –– A hearing on a motion to dismiss double-murder charges against Michael J. Pierce of Quilcene is extending into a fourth day after testimony from psychological experts failed to conclude again Tuesday.

“I want everybody to know, in no uncertain terms, this is ending tomorrow,” Kitsap County Superior Court Judge Sally Olsen said after Tuesday’s testimony.

Asks for dismissal

Richard Davies of Port Townsend, attorney for Pierce, 38, of Quilcene, has asked the court to dismiss the charges, arguing that a pair of mistrials in Jefferson County’s second effort to prosecute him for the murders of Quilcene farm couple Pat and Janice Yarr in March 2009 ended because of egregious errors by the state.

Pierce was convicted by a Jefferson County jury in 2010 of two counts of first-degree murder as well as one count each of first-degree burglary, first-degree robbery, first-degree arson, theft of a firearm, second-degree unlawful possession of a firearm and second-degree theft.

He was serving a life sentence in prison when the state Court of Appeals overturned the conviction in 2012.

Pierce has been tried two times since, once in Jefferson County and once in Kitsap County, with both ending in mistrials.

A third retrial is set Oct. 9 in Kitsap County Superior Court.

Olsen has been hearing testimony on Davies’ motion since Friday.

‘Barbaric’ treatment

Davies cited “barbaric” treatment by Kitsap County when Pierce’s psychotropic medications were discontinued while he was jailed for the Kitsap County retrial.

After discovering medications were denied Pierce from March 7-10, Olsen ruled his right to a fair trial had been “impossibly infringed” and declared a mistrial.

On the stand Tuesday was Dr. Kapil Chopra, a psychiatrist from Sound Mental Health who contracts with Conmed to serve as Kitsap County’s jail psychiatrist.

Chopra will continue his testimony at 9:30 a.m. Wednesday in Kitsap County Superior Court, 614 N. Division St., Port Orchard.

After appearing in an orange jumpsuit through the first three days of the hearing, Pierce requested to attend Wednesday morning’s hearing via online camera, a request Olsen granted.

Pierce was given a 14-day “bridge” prescription for anti-psychotic medications by Kitsap County jailers after he arrived there for the retrial in February, Chopra said.

Medications were stopped March 7 after the “bridge” prescription expired, he said, but he was not aware of that until a mental health assessment with Pierce on March 11.

‘Not able to follow up’

Inmates needing treatment for mental health issues are typically first seen by a licensed nurse practitioner after being booked, who then sets up assessments with Chopra, who visits the Kitsap County jail Tuesdays.

He originally was scheduled to see Pierce on March 4.

“Unfortunately, Mr. Pierce was in court, and I was not able to follow up with him,” Chopra said Tuesday.

Chopra said he never received a phone call to extend Pierce’s medication after the bridge expired March 7, as should have been done, he said, under Conmed’s policies.

“Had the policies, procedures and protocol been followed correctly, the way they are, Mr. Pierce would have been able to have his medications continued until he was seen by me,” Chopra said.

He said patients receiving medication to control psychosis should not have their medications cut off.

“We recommend slowly tapering off the medications,” Chopra said.

Background

The state Court of Appeals overturned Pierce’s conviction on the grounds that his constitutional rights were denied after his arrest and that Prosecuting Attorney Scott Rosekrans’ closing argument in the original trial represented prosecutorial misconduct.

After an investigation, the Washington State Bar Association later cleared Rosekrans of ethical violations for speculating during closing arguments what the Yarrs and Pierce were thinking during the night of the murders.

________

Sequim-Dungeness Valley Editor Joe Smillie can be reached at 360-681-2390, ext. 5052, or at jsmillie@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Rear Admiral Charles E. Fosse, right, U.S. Coast Guard District 13 commander, was the guest speaker at the U.S. Coast Guard Station Port Angeles’ annual Veterans Day celebration on Monday. Chaplain Mike VanProyen, left, and Kelly Higgins, the commanding officer at Coast Guard Air Station Port Angeles, also participated in the ceremony. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Hundreds gather in Port Angeles to honor service members

High school band, choral groups highlight event

Former Marine Joseph Schwann of Port Townsend smiles as he receives a Quilt of Valor from Kathy Darrow, right, and another member of Quilts of Valor during the Veterans Day event at the American Legion Marvin G. Shields Memorial Post 26 in Port Townsend on Monday. Group leader Kathey Bates, left, was the emcee of the event. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Quilts of Valor

Former Marine Joseph Schwann of Port Townsend smiles as he receives a… Continue reading

Port Townsend ethics complaint dismissed

Officer examines argument on open meetings

Friends of the Library to host annual meeting

The Port Angeles Friends of the Library will conduct… Continue reading

Peninsula College to stage ‘The Thanksgiving Play’

Peninsula College will present its production of “The Thanksgiving… Continue reading

Ceramic sculpture “Flora-Fauna” by Thomas Connery.
Library to host reception for ‘Second Look’ exhibition

The North Olympic Library System will host a reception… Continue reading

Sequim City Council members finalized through their consent agenda to ban the sale of fireworks effective October 2025. They held a public hearing last month that garnered mostly support for the ban. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim finalizes ban on fireworks

Ordinance change will go into effect next October

Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Rich Krebsbach, manager of the Highland Irrigation District, asks questions of Rhiana Barkie, Clallam County public works project coordinator. The map is one of four new options for the Dungeness Off-Channel Reservoir project. Public input is being taken through the county’s website at https://www.clallamcountywa.gov/188/Dungeness-Off-Channel-Reservoir-Project.
Sequim reservoir project draws crowd, questions

Clallam County, FEMA public comment period open through Nov. 21

Christmas gift inspires playground cleanup

Veteran volunteer collects playground metal

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

World War II veteran Arthur Bradow, right, and his daughter Barbara Cason admire a quilt sewn by his niece for his 100th birthday on Dec. 13. Bradow served in the Merchant Marine in the Pacific Theater of Operations and stateside in the U.S. Army Air Forces. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Veteran has 100 years’ worth of experience

Looks back at long life and wealth of knowledge

Veterans Day ceremonies set

Organizations across the Peninsula will conduct a variety of services in observance… Continue reading