Port Angeles man’s conviction reversed by Court of Appeals on grounds of ineffective counsel

TACOMA — A Port Angeles man’s October conviction of unlawful possession of a firearm has been overturned.

The state Court of Appeals on March 15 reversed a Clallam County jury verdict convicting Aaron Maurice Mylan, 25, of unlawful possession of a firearm in the first degree, saying he had been ineffectively defended by counsel.

The ruling sets the stage for a potential retrial, Clallam County Prosecuting Attorney Mark Nichols said Friday.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

“Unless the Washington Supreme Court overturns the Court of Appeals, Mylan will return to Clallam County for a new trial,” Nichols said.

A jury found Mylan not guilty of one count of first-degree robbery, two counts of second-degree assault and one count of theft of a motor vehicle, convicting him only on the firearm charge.

The charges stemmed from a roadside altercation in Forks on Aug. 24, 2014.

Mylan said Diamond Mueller attacked him after he had asked him to stop selling drugs to his friend. The two were in Mueller’s truck.

Mylan said Mueller stopped the truck, pulled out a gun, put it to Mylan’s head and began yelling at him.

They struggled for the gun, Mylan said, adding that it discharged, missing both of them.

Mylan said he managed to eject the magazine, which Mueller began using as a weapon with which to hit him.

Mylan said he was able to take control of the gun and struck Mueller in the head three or four times with the side of the gun, after which a bloodied Mueller rolled backward out of the open driver’s side door and onto the ground.

Mueller said Mylan was attempting to steal his truck.

On appeal, Mylan said his attorney should have requested instruction allowing the jury to find that he possessed Mueller’s firearm by necessity to keep Mueller from shooting him.

The appeals court agreed, saying Mylan’s trial counsel failed to defend the firearm charge at all and that Mylan was prejudiced by his counsel’s deficient performance.

“Mylan was under an unlawful present threat of death or serious bodily injury, he did not recklessly place himself in that situation, he had no reasonable legal alternative to his actions, and threat of harm from Mueller was the direct cause for his momentary possession and disposal of the gun,” the Court of Appeals said.

“Therefore, we hold that Mylan was entitled to a necessity instruction based on the evidence.”

Mylan currently is serving a sentence of 105 months at the state prison in Monroe. He has four prior convictions for burglary, two for delivery of a controlled substance and three for forgery and trafficking in stolen property, theft and assault, Nichols said.

________

Reporter Chris McDaniel can be reached at 360-452-2345, ext. 56650, or cmcdaniel@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

A portion of the crowd at the Hands Off rally, which started at the intersection of Laurel and First Street. An estimated 800 to 1,000 people attended in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/For Peninsula Daily News)
Hands Off! protests on Peninsula

A portion of the crowd at the Hands Off rally, which started… Continue reading

Kathy Cruz/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Susan Fisch, standing, chair of the Clallam County Charter Review Commission, addresses a crowd of residents who packed the meeting room at KSQM FM (91.5) last month for the first of several town hall events. Speakers were allowed up to three minutes to share their views about issues related to the charter that they consider most important.
Charter meeting draws crowd

Open house set tonight in Joyce

Weekly flight operations scheduled

There will be field carrier landing practice operations for aircraft… Continue reading

Margo Karler of Port Townsend looks up at the plaster covers protecting a tusk that was found by hikers on the beach near the Point Wilson lighthouse in March. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Fossil found in sandstone bluff at Fort Worden

State Parks, Burke museum developing plan for preservation

Ian’s Ride receives volunteer service award

Ian’s Ride has received a Washington State Volunteer Service Award… Continue reading

Boating coach Eric Lesch, at a whiteboard, explains sailing techniques to a youth sailboat class. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Teenagers learning boating skills through program

Nonprofit funded by grants, agencies and donations

Land trust successful with campaign fund

Public access expected to open this year

Mark Hodgson.
Hodgson plans to run for Port Angeles City Council

Schromen-Wawrin, who currently holds seat, won’t run again

Pet vaccination clinic set for Saturday in Port Townsend

Pet Helpers of Port Townsend will conduct a pet… Continue reading