Port Angeles plaintiff in health care suit hears arguments

PORT ANGELES — Former lawyer and investment banker Kaj Ahlburg said Friday he listened to recordings of last week’s oral arguments before the U.S. Supreme Court over a history-making case that bears his name and could touch more than 30 million Americans.

But he continued to maintain his staunch silence about how and why he decided to become one of the few individual plaintiffs who joined 26 states, including Washington, in challenging President Barack Obama’s Patient Protection and Affordable Health Care Act, called Obamacare by its critics.

After six hours of oral arguments Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday, the court was behind closed doors Friday, voting on the case in a decision not expected to be made public until June, after the jurists write majority and minority opinions.

“My purpose was not to seek publicity,” said Ahlburg, 52.

“It did not enter into my consideration.”

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

His wife, Laura, joined him in listening to some of the oral arguments, he said.

Won’t go into details

“I won’t get into the details of which parts I listened to and which parts I didn’t,” he said.

“Sometimes there’s been publicity around cases that has not been positively perceived by the judges, who feel in some way that publicity is not appropriate or just don’t think it helps the case.”

“Statements are not helpful while the case is in progress, so I am refraining.”

Supreme Court pundits said the judges’ questions during oral arguments indicated the outcome will be in Ahlburg’s, not Obama’s, favor.

“A good judge will ask searching questions of both parties and not necessarily reveal what they are thinking,” Ahlburg said.

The law requires all Americans to buy health insurance — especially the estimated 30 million to 50 million who don’t have it — or pay a penalty of $95 in 2014 that increases to $695 in 2016.

Proponents say the mandate is necessary to pay for the health care of all Americans.

Ahlburg’s name was added as a plaintiff in the case May 14, 2010.

“Mr. Ahlburg is and reasonably expects to remain financially able to pay for his own health care services if and as needed,” the amended complaint said.

“Mr. Ahlburg will be subject to the mandate and objects to being forced to comply with it and objects to the Act’s unconstitutional overreaching and its encroachment on the states’ sovereignty.”

Ahlburg’s lawyer, Gregory Katsas of Washington, D.C., did not return a call for comment Saturday.

________

Senior Staff Writer Paul Gottlieb can be reached at 360-417-3536 or at paul.gottlieb@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

Caro Tchannie and her daughter Lola Hatch, 9, of Tulallip try a long string of beads at Squatchcon on Thursday at the Vern Burton Community Center gym in Port Angeles. Kevin VanDinter of Port Angeles was one of 60 vendors at the four day event, which continues through Sunday. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Squatchcon underway

Caro Tchannie and her daughter Lola Hatch, 9, of Tulallip try a… Continue reading

Capital budgets include Peninsula

Millions in state funds earmarked

Mike Chapman.
Chapman asks not to employ legislative privilege

State senator removes an exemption to Public Records Act

Port of Port Townsend considering Short’s Farm access

Commissioners aim to balance public, agricultural use

Jefferson library director to start new job May 19

Meet-and-greet event scheduled for May 22

Man taken to hospital after car hits tree

A man was transported to a hospital after a single-car… Continue reading

Bypass roads to be installed at two fish passage sites

Contractors will begin construction of one-lane bypass roads at two… Continue reading

Emily Matthiessen/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Stew Cockburn stands in the spring annual section prior to it being for early spring gardeners.
New Dungeness Nursery planted in landscaping industry

Family and their employees work 2-acre location in Sequim

Partnership discussion may violate state law

OMC in Phase 2 of exploratory process

Members of the public take a guided tour at Port Townsend High School on Wednesday. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
Port Townsend school district may seek $90M bond

Tour highlights high school’s infrastructure needs

A pair of wind surfers take off from the breakwater at Port Townsend Marina in an apparent race across the bay on Tuesday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Catching the wind

A pair of wind surfers take off from the breakwater at Port… Continue reading