Retrial sought in evidence room theft conviction

PORT ANGELES — A judge will decide next month whether Staci Allison, a former Clallam County Sheriff’s Office employee who was convicted of stealing $8,644 from the office’s evidence room, should have a retrial.

An eight-woman, four-man jury found Allison, 41, guilty of first-degree theft and money laundering last month in Clallam County Superior Court.

Her attorney, Ralph Anderson, is seeking a retrial for the money-laundering conviction, claiming the charge was not justified.

He also plans to appeal the theft conviction, saying the evidence didn’t support the conviction.

A hearing will be held Dec. 15 in Superior Court.

Allison, who faces up to 10 years in prison, would be sentenced that day if the retrial motion is denied.

A sentencing hearing, set for last Thursday was delayed so that Anderson’s motions could be heard.

Money laundering

Anderson said he doesn’t believe putting money into a bank account should qualify as money laundering.

“In a legal sense, I think that’s overly broad and vague,” he said.

Anderson also said he doesn’t believe there was enough evidence to support a theft conviction.

“You don’t expect to win these motions, but you never know,” he said.

If the case is not granted a retrial, Anderson said he would appeal both convictions.

Allison was convicted of stealing the funds by emptying evidence bags containing the money and altering some computer records.

The Sheriff’s Office discovered money was missing in November 2006 when 129 empty evidence bags once containing $51,251 were found stuffed in a plastic tube.

Allison was charged with taking a fraction of that amount because that’s how much prosecutors felt they could prove she stole.

That was based on computer records she had altered, according to testimony.

Out on bond

Allison was placed into custody immediately after her conviction but has been out on a $10,000 bond since Oct. 24.

She was the second former county employee convicted of stealing funds while on the job this year.

The other, Catherine Betts, was sentenced to 12 years in prison in August for stealing between $617,467 and $793,595 in real estate excise tax proceeds between June 2003 and May 2009 while she worked as a cashier in the Treasurer’s Office.

She is also required to pay $607,516 in restitution to the county.

Authorities have said the thefts are not connected.

None of the money from the cases was recovered.

________

Reporter Tom Callis can be reached at 360-417-3532 or at tom.callis@peninsuladailynews.com.

More in News

A group demonstrates in front of the Clallam County Courthouse on Lincoln Street in Port Angeles on Monday. The event, sponsored by the Clallam Palestine Action Group, was set on Martin Luther King Jr. day for a national mobilization for peace and justice, according to a press release. They were to focus on workers’ rights, immigrants’ rights, environmental justice and a free Palestine. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
‘Peace and justice’

A group demonstrates in front of the Clallam County Courthouse on Lincoln… Continue reading

Timeline set for Port Angeles School District search

Board expects to name leader in March

Gesturing toward the Olympic Mountains, Erik Kingfisher of Jefferson Land Trust leads a site tour with project architect Richard Berg and Olympic Housing Trust board trustee Kristina Stimson. (Olympic Housing Trust)
Jefferson Land Trust secures housing grant from Commerce

Partner agency now developing plans for affordable homes

Chaplain Kathi Gregoire poses with Scout, her 4-year-old mixed breed dog. Scout is training to be a therapy dog to join Gregoire on future community calls with either the Clallam County Sheriff’s Office or the Washington State Patrol. (Clallam County Sheriff’s Office)
Clallam County chaplain adding K9 to team

Volunteer duo working to become certified

Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News
About 700 participants took part in the 2025 People's March on Saturday in Port Townsend.The march went from the Quimper Mercantile parking lot to Pope Marine Park, a distance of 5 blocks. Formerly known as the Women's March, the name was changed this year to the People's March in order to be more inclusive.
People’s March in Port Townsend

About 700 participants took part in the 2025 People’s March on Saturday… Continue reading

Due to Helen Haller Elementary’s age, antiquated equipment, limited amenities, such as bathrooms, costs for renovation and many other factors, Sequim School District leaders are proposing a new elementary school as part of the Feb. 11 construction bond. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim school bond aims to address safety

Special election ballots mailed Wednesday

Clallam County Fire District 3 firefighters look to contain a fire in 2024. Calls for fires were down last year, but general calls for service were up from 2023. (Beau Sylte/Clallam County Fire District 3)
Fire districts in Sequim, Port Angeles see record numbers in 2024

Departments adding staff, focusing on connecting patients to resources

Rod Dirks enjoys affection from his 2-year-old daughter Maeli, who expresses confidence that doctors will heal her dad’s cancer. (Emily Matthiessen/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim man fighting rare form of cancer

Family faces uncertainty buoyed by community support

Ballots to be mailed Wednesday for special election

Four school districts put forward measures

Connor Cunningham of Port Townsend, an employee of the Port of Port Townsend, hangs a sign for new business owner Lori Hanemann of Port Townsend on Friday at her shop in what was a former moorage office at Point Hudson Marina. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Shop sign

Connor Cunningham of Port Townsend, an employee of the Port of Port… Continue reading

Teenager receives heart transplant after 12-hour surgery

Additional surgery was expected to close chest