Sequim: Would John Wayne solve a crime this way?

SEQUIM — It’s not the way The Duke would have solved crimes in his big-screen western days.

But it did the trick for Sequim police officers, who used fingerprinting technology to find the guy they believe lifted a replica pistol housed in a display case filled with memorabilia from the late movie star’s namesake venue — John Wayne Marina.

A 38-year-old Maple Valley man who police identified as Rhett Whitchurch was booked into Clallam County jail on Friday for investigation of theft in the third degree after fingerprints taken from display-case glass matched a set of his prints stored in a computerized law enforcement database, said Sequim police Sgt. Sean Madison.

Whitchurch has a criminal history, but no known ties to the North Olympic Peninsula, Madison said.

And that’s what makes cracking the case all the more intriguing, Madison said.

“It’s really unusual. It rarely happens,” Madison said of the department’s ability to match the prints.

“Fingerprints are a wonderful thing, but first of all they have to exist, and we have to be able to find them and retrieve them.

“Then they have to be of a quality you can use them to compare them to what we call a ‘known.”‘

In this case, the “known” is someone who allegedly made his way into a John Wayne Marina building east of Sequim on Sept. 20, 2003.

The suspect removed the glass plates covering one of four cases filled with relics from Wayne’s movies, and made off with only a replica pistol.

The burglar didn’t take the holster housing the fake gun, according to the original police report.

More in News

Tracy Ryan, a nurse at Jefferson Healthcare in Port Townsend, stands in front of one of the hospital’s maternity ward rooms. (Grace Deng/Washington State Standard)
Rural maternity wards are struggling to stay afloat

State and federal lawmakers are trying to help

Jefferson County approves transportation plan

Six-year improvement outlook budgeted for more than $94M

Rainwater collection presentation canceled

The Rainwater Collection 101 presentation scheduled for 6:30 p.m.… Continue reading

Rear Admiral Charles E. Fosse, right, U.S. Coast Guard District 13 commander, was the guest speaker at the U.S. Coast Guard Station Port Angeles’ annual Veterans Day celebration on Monday. Chaplain Mike VanProyen, left, and Kelly Higgins, the commanding officer at Coast Guard Air Station Port Angeles, also participated in the ceremony. (Paula Hunt/Peninsula Daily News)
Hundreds gather in Port Angeles to honor service members

High school band, choral groups highlight event

Former Marine Joseph Schwann of Port Townsend smiles as he receives a Quilt of Valor from Kathy Darrow, right, and another member of Quilts of Valor during the Veterans Day event at the American Legion Marvin G. Shields Memorial Post 26 in Port Townsend on Monday. Group leader Kathey Bates, left, was the emcee of the event. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Quilts of Valor

Former Marine Joseph Schwann of Port Townsend smiles as he receives a… Continue reading

Port Townsend ethics complaint dismissed

Officer examines argument on open meetings

Friends of the Library to host annual meeting

The Port Angeles Friends of the Library will conduct… Continue reading

Peninsula College to stage ‘The Thanksgiving Play’

Peninsula College will present its production of “The Thanksgiving… Continue reading

Ceramic sculpture “Flora-Fauna” by Thomas Connery.
Library to host reception for ‘Second Look’ exhibition

The North Olympic Library System will host a reception… Continue reading

Sequim City Council members finalized through their consent agenda to ban the sale of fireworks effective October 2025. They held a public hearing last month that garnered mostly support for the ban. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Sequim finalizes ban on fireworks

Ordinance change will go into effect next October

Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Rich Krebsbach, manager of the Highland Irrigation District, asks questions of Rhiana Barkie, Clallam County public works project coordinator. The map is one of four new options for the Dungeness Off-Channel Reservoir project. Public input is being taken through the county’s website at https://www.clallamcountywa.gov/188/Dungeness-Off-Channel-Reservoir-Project.
Sequim reservoir project draws crowd, questions

Clallam County, FEMA public comment period open through Nov. 21