Subminimum wage for disabled workers called ‘unjust’

Several states considering similar legislation

  • By Patric Haerle WNPA News Service
  • Sunday, February 7, 2021 1:30am
  • News

By Patric Haerle

WNPA News Service

OLYMPIA — Lawmakers are considering ending the decades old practice of paying workers with a disability less than the state minimum wage.

Advocates say it’s past time to take action on the issue.

“We’re back at this work again this year because it’s a civil rights issue to pay people with disabilities less than minimum wage,” said Sen. Emily Randall, D-Bremerton, at a public hearing of the bill on Feb. 1.

Randall introduced a similar bill in 2019 that never got out of committee.

Current system

Under the current system, the Department of Labor and Industries can allow employers to pay workers with disabilities wage less than the state minimum.

To qualify, employers must describe how the disability negatively impacts earnings and what the proposed wage would be.

There is no set floor for how low the wages can be, as long as employers get approval from the U.S Department of Labor to pay less than the federal minimum wage of $7.25 per hour.

This practice predates by more than three decades the Americans with Disabilities Act, which prohibits discrimination based on disability.

Seattle eliminated subminimum wage for workers with disabilities in 2018, and in 2020 Washington state agencies did the same.

“Continuing to allow subminimum wage lets employers treat folks with disabilities as less than,” Randall said. “That is simply unjust and it hurts everyone in our communities. It hurts our economy, and it marginalizes our neighbors.”

Among those who testified in support, were advocates who had worked for far under minimum wage in the past.

“I … worked a six-hour-a-day job over the summer of 2003, and only made roughly $70 every two weeks,” said John Lemus, an advocacy coordinator for AtWork!, which helps establish job connections for people with disabilities.

“This is absolutely unacceptable, and we should not allow it to happen anymore. This is either going to happen at the state level, or it will happen at the federal level in the next two years, and you will be told how to do it.”

In the past several years, several states have eliminated subminimum wages.

Randall reshaped her bill from 2019 to address concerns brought up by caretakers, who say differences from person to person should be addressed.

“While I understand the intentions of this bill, I have great concerns about the collateral damage not being addressed,” said Cheryl Felak, a registered nurse and guardian for her adult son who works with a developmental disability.

“Safeguards are currently in place to prevent any exploitation or discrimination for people who choose this type of employment. Eliminating this choice will not improve the socioeconomic status of any of the participants,” Felak said. “There has been no study on the outcome of previous changes.”

The bill would phase out the current program, preventing L&I from issuing any subminimum wage certificates after July of 2023.

More in News

Paul Gottlieb
Retired reporter highlights impactful stories

Suicide prevention, fluoride two significant topics

Expenses to outpace revenue for Clallam Fire District 2

Projection based on rejection of levy lid lift

David Gritskie of Stripe Rite from Bremerton guides a stripe painting machine Wednesday east of Port Angeles City Hall. The new parking lot is using permeable pavement over a layer of gravel of 2 feet to 4 feet thick. The project is retrofitting the east city hall parking lot with a new stormwater detention and treatment infrastructure. The project will help manage runoff, slow down peak flow and remove pollutants before connecting and flowing into Peabody Creek. The parking lot will reopen to the public on Monday. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Parking lot project

David Gritskie of Stripe Rite from Bremerton guides a stripe painting machine… Continue reading

Looking to stay cool, several people jump off the Rainbow Bridge over the Devil’s Punch Bowl on the Spruce Railroad Trail on Lake Crescent in Olympic National Park over Labor Day weekend. A heat advisory has been issued by the National Weather Service with temperatures expected to reach the 80s and possibly the low 90s through today. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Heat advisory

Looking to stay cool, several people jump off the Rainbow Bridge over… Continue reading

Port Angeles police to join program to help those in need

Funding could pay for food, hotel or other means of aid

Port Townsend sewer pipe could be replaced by Friday

Sinkhole expedites work projected for this winter

Olympic Medical Center’s financial picture improving year over year

Hospital’s net losses $10M ahead of past 12 months

Clallam County hosting online climate risk survey

The Clallam County Department of Community Development is conducting… Continue reading

Violet Wilkie looks to see how her classmate Sylas Hall is coloring his name tag, the first chore on the first day of school Tuesday in Danika Johnson’s first-grade classroom at Hamilton Elementary in Port Angeles. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Welcome back

Violet Wilkie looks to see how her classmate Sylas Hall is coloring… Continue reading

COVID-19 rates are high on Peninsula

Vaccinations for latest variant are arriving

Advocates debate four initiatives to appear on November ballot

Choices to be made on climate act, capital gains, long-term care, natural gas

Abbey Molyneux, from Norfolk, United Kingdom, also known as Abbey the Boat Builder, poses at Northwest Maritime in Port Townsend on Tuesday. (Steve Mullensky/for Peninsula Daily News)
Festival to celebrate women in boat building

Three hundred vessels to tie up at Point Hudson for three-day event