Signs are posted at a entrance to the Hanford Nuclear Reservation in Richland on May 9, 2017. (Manuel Valdes/The Associated Press)

Signs are posted at a entrance to the Hanford Nuclear Reservation in Richland on May 9, 2017. (Manuel Valdes/The Associated Press)

Trump officials blamed for slowing down nuke site cleanup

Budget cuts proposed at same time estimated cost has tripled

  • By Nicholas K. Geranios The Associated Press
  • Tuesday, April 9, 2019 1:30am
  • News

By Nicholas K. Geranios

The Associated Press

SPOKANE — The slow pace of cleaning up the nation’s largest cache of radioactive waste left over from the production of nuclear weapons is frustrating Washington state officials from both major political parties, who blame the Trump administration for not doing more.

The U.S. Department of Energy recently proposed hundreds of millions of dollars in budget cuts for cleaning up the vast Hanford Nuclear Reservation in southeastern Washington, even though the estimated cost of the cleanup has at least tripled and could reach more than $600 billion.

“That’s a huge, huge cost increase,” said Tom Carpenter, director of the watchdog group Hanford Challenge.

ADVERTISEMENT
0 seconds of 0 secondsVolume 0%
Press shift question mark to access a list of keyboard shortcuts
00:00
00:00
00:00
 

At a recent hearing in Washington, D.C., Democratic Sen. Patty Murray questioned Energy Secretary Rick Perry’s assertion that his agency can still meet a legally binding cleanup schedule despite the proposed budget cuts.

Much of the site’s aging infrastructure is deteriorating, including underground waste storage tanks and tunnels.

The Energy Department issued a report in January that raised the remaining cost of Hanford’s environmental cleanup to between $323 billion and $677 billion, with the work lasting until 2079 or 2102, depending on which estimate proves true.

That is much higher than the previous estimate of $107 billion in costs to complete the cleanup by 2066.

That is “a pretty shocking number,” Perry told members of the House Appropriations Committee late last month.

Shortly after the higher estimates were revealed, the Trump administration proposed a $416 million cut in its budget for Hanford that would reduce it from about $2.5 billion for the fiscal year ending Sept. 30 to $2.1 billion for the next fiscal year that starts Oct. 1.

Republican U.S. Rep. Dan Newhouse, whose district encompasses the site, said the administration’s “budget request numbers would fall short of fulfilling the federal government’s obligation to clean up the Hanford site.”

U.S. Sen. Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, estimated it will take 300 years to clean up the site under the Trump administration’s proposed budget.

“Trump’s combination of bad math and shifty wordplay adds up to tragicomic incompetence,” said Wyden, a frequent critic of efforts to clean up the site.

Washington state officials have said previously — even before the cuts were announced — that the federal government has not provided enough funding to meet annual cleanup costs. They have suggested that at least $3 billion annually is needed.

“We believe that the lack of adequate funding translates into a longer, more drawn-out cleanup, and that in turn is a significant factor in the increased cost of the total cleanup,” said Alex Smith, manager of nuclear waste programs for the Washington Department of Ecology.

Hanford was created by the Manhattan Project during World War II as the nation raced to build atomic bombs. The plutonium for the atomic bomb dropped on Nagasaki, Japan, at the end of the war was made at the site, which then produced about 70 percent of the plutonium for the U.S. Cold War arsenal.

That left the country’s largest volume of radioactive waste at the site about half the size of Rhode Island, where the most dangerous 56 million gallons of waste is stored in 177 giant underground tanks, some of which have leaked.

The site has around 10,000 workers and is the main economic force for the cities of Richland, Pasco and Kennewick, located 200 miles east of Seattle.

Carpenter said he suspected the larger cleanup cost estimate followed by the Trump administration announcement on the proposed Hanford budget cut could be part of a larger government plan to limit the cleanup’s scope.

He pointed out that the Energy Department mounted a campaign in recent years to reclassify much of Hanford’s dangerous high-level waste as low-level, which would reduce cleanup costs.

Washington officials want “to walk away from Hanford and the cleanup. They want to put concrete in the tanks and walk away,” he said.

Perry said the Trump administration will keep promises for continued cleanup work.

“We give you our commitment that, not only are we going to be working efficiently, but we’re going to be working timely,” Perry said at the congressional hearing.

More in News

Story swap

Erran Sharpe will be the featured speaker… Continue reading

Gary Norris, front, takes a photo of the Rayonier No. 4 as Leo Frymire looks on during a tour of the engine on Sunday at Lauridsen Boulevard and Chase Street in Port Angeles. They attended a fundraiser for Restore the 4!, a local group leading the effort to restore the geared locomotive built in 1924 by Willamette Iron and Steel in Portland, Ore. The North Olympic History Center, which helped organize the event, donated $1,000 toward the cause. More than 100 people attended a presentation by Steve Hauff, a local historian and expert on Willamette logging locomotives, at the Port Angeles Main Library beforehand. (Keith Thorpe/Peninsula Daily News)
Locomotive fundraiser

Gary Norris, front, takes a photo of the Rayonier No. 4 as… Continue reading

Court denies recall petition

Sequim man files motion to reconsider

Former Washington Supreme Court Justice Susan Owens dies

Judge spent 19 years on Clallam County District Court bench

Boatbuilding school names executive director

Local candidate chosen from national pool

Road improvement project set at Lincoln Park

The city of Port Angeles will perform road improvements… Continue reading

Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group
Sisters Jasmine Kirchan, left, and Shawnta Henry and their mom Nicole Kirchan all work at the Sequim Boys & Girls Club. After work on Feb. 26, they all helped save the life of a man in front of Walmart.
Sequim woman uses CPR training to save man outside Walmart

She credits training to Boys Girls Club, fire district

The 104-lot Bell Creek Major Subdivision and 24-lot Bella Vista Estates recently were approved by Sequim Hearing Examiner Peregrin Sorter. (Matthew Nash/Olympic Peninsula News Group)
Hearing examiner approves 2 projects

Developments could add 128 homes in Sequim

No flight operations scheduled this week

There will be no field carrier landing practice operations for… Continue reading

2024 timber revenue shows Jefferson below average, Clallam on par

DNR timber delay could impact 2025 timber revenue

Forks council looks to fill vacant seat

The Forks City Council is accepting applications to fill a… Continue reading