Unions join fight over proposed state water rules involving fish consumption

  • By Phuong Le The Associated Press
  • Friday, June 20, 2014 12:01am
  • News

By Phuong Le

The Associated Press

SEATTLE — Unions representing Boeing machinists and millworkers are siding with businesses in a bitter fight over how much fish people eat, and thus how clean Washington state waters should be.

The Machinists union and others are worried a new water quality standard being developed by the state would hurt jobs and economic development.

“We want clean water,” said Tanya Hutchins, a spokeswoman for the Machinists union, which represents more than 32,000 workers in Puget Sound.

“We just want to make sure it’s a proposal that works for everyone.”

Officials from the Machinists union, the Association of Western Pulp and Paper Workers and others held a news conference Monday in Olympia to urge Gov. Jay Inslee to take a balanced approach.

The state Department of Ecology appears ready to sharply increase Washington’s fish consumption rate, an obscure number that has huge implications because it helps set water quality standards.

A higher number means fewer toxic pollutants would be permitted in waters.

The agency has been deliberating for months, with tribes, commercial fishermen and environmental groups lining up on one side, and Boeing Co., business groups and municipalities on the other.

A draft rule is expected this summer that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency must approve.

The EPA has told Washington that its current rate doesn’t sufficiently protect those who eat the most fish, particularly Native Americans and Pacific Islanders.

The federal agency also has warned Washington officials it plans to take over the process if the state doesn’t come up with a final rule by the end of 2014.

“The governor has been clear that this decision will be guided by a commitment to healthy people, clean water and a strong economy,” Inslee’s spokeswoman, Jaime Smith, said Monday.

Studies have shown Washington residents eat more fish than other people nationwide.

The state currently assumes people eat about 6½ grams a day — or about a small fillet once a month.

The state is considering raising that fish consumption rate to between 125 and 225 grams of fish a day.

Oregon set its rate at 175 grams a day, the highest for a U.S. state.

Tribes, environmental groups, commercial fishermen and others are pressing for a higher rate that protects all people.

They urge Inslee and the state to prevent cancer-causing pollutants from entering the state’s waters.

Northwest tribes, in particular, are concerned about the fish consumption rate because fish and shellfish play an important role in the diet and culture of its members.

Businesses, cities and counties, meanwhile, worry standards will be set so high they can’t be achieved.

Boeing in March raised concerns to Inslee that the proposals “will have unintended consequences for continued Boeing production in the state.”

They note technology doesn’t exist in some cases to limit certain pollutants.

Environmental groups argue the standards would drive technological innovations.

More in News

Crew members from the USS Pomfret, including Lt. Jimmy Carter, who would go on to become the 39th president of the United States, visit the Elks Lodge in Port Angeles in October 1949. (Beegee Capos)
Former President Carter once visited Port Angeles

Former mayor recalls memories of Jimmy Carter

Thursday’s paper to be delivered Friday

Peninsula Daily News will have an electronic edition on… Continue reading

Counties agree on timber revenue

Recommendation goes to state association

Port of Port Angeles, tribe agree to land swap

Stormwater ponds critical for infrastructure upgrades

Poet Laureate Conner Bouchard-Roberts is exploring the overlap between poetry and civic discourse. (Elijah Sussman/Peninsula Daily News)
PT poet laureate seeks new civic language

City library has hosted events for Bouchard-Roberts

Five taken to hospitals after three-car collision

Five people were taken to three separate hospitals following a… Continue reading

John Gatchet of Gardiner, left, and Mike Tabak of Vancouver, B.C., use their high-powered scopes to try to spot an Arctic loon. The recent Audubon Christmas Bird Count reported the sighting of the bird locally so these bird enthusiasts went to the base of Ediz Hook in search of the loon on Sunday afternoon. (Dave Logan/for Peninsula Daily News)
Bird watchers

John Gatchet of Gardiner, left, and Mike Tabak of Vancouver, B.C., use… Continue reading

Forks schools to ask for levy

Measure on Feb. 11 special election ballot

Jefferson County commissioners name Pernsteiner acting sheriff

Jefferson Democrats to nominate three interim candidates

State commission fines fire commissioner

PDC says Kraft owes more than $4,600

Marine Center receives $15 million

Funding comes from Inflation Reduction Act

Port Townsend creates new department to oversee creative district

Melody Sky Weaver appointed director of Community Service Department