A man-made log jam in the Hoh River is seen here falling apart 15 years after its creation. (Pat Neal/for Peninsula Daily News)

A man-made log jam in the Hoh River is seen here falling apart 15 years after its creation. (Pat Neal/for Peninsula Daily News)

PAT NEAL: The Hoh rocks

IT’S BEEN ANOTHER tough week in the news.

The Upper Hoh Road washed out again. This popular entrance to Olympic National Park welcomes over 80,000 cars a year up to the fee station where tourists can wait over an hour in the summer to get in.

Losing the road eliminates one of the biggest tourist attractions on the Olympic Peninsula.

It washes out about every year when a gully washer combines with a rising freezing level into a perfect storm of muddy water, logs and rocks rolling down the mountain destroying everything in its path.

Floods have been happening since the ice age. The problem was only noticed after the Upper Hoh Road was built.

The old timers said the road should have been built up on the sidehill away from the river, but no. The government built the road right along the river and it’s been washing out ever since.

It’s no wonder. The Hoh River routinely eats vast forests, chewing them up and spitting them out into giant log jams.

It grinds mountains into rubble washing downstream until it’s dumped on the ocean floor.

Man-made objects mean nothing to the Hoh River.

Nothing can stop the power of the Hoh River to eventually go where it wants to go.

There’s only a temporary Band-Aid fix and it’s expensive.

The only defense against the awesome power of the river are rocks, big ones and lots of them stacked up to protect the road from the river.

Called rip rap, these rocks are the only reason the Upper Hoh Road has been open this long.

Lately the practice of armoring roads with rip rap to save them from the river has fallen out of favor with the salmon restoration industry, which claims the practice harms fish.

They prefer to build log jams to attempt to control the destructive power of the river.

This ignores the fact our rivers flow out of mountains of rocks through rock-lined canyons across rocky bottomlands into a rocky ocean.

The fish were doing just fine with rocks until Europeans got here.

Are rocks put in rivers to save our roads bad for fish? How come some of our best fishing holes are along sections of the river armored with rip rap? Do fish prefer wood? Can they tell the difference? Or is it just another case of the salmon restoration industry spending as much grant money as it can?

Attempts to control the Hoh River with log jams were tried back in the last century.

It was a failure.

The locals were outraged.

In 2005 they spent $8 million building eight log jams to protect Highway 101 along the lower Hoh.

Fifteen years later the logs are rotting and floating away leaving ugly metal landmarks of this failed policy.

The Hoh River is commonly referred to as “the last best river in America.”

It’s a river of big fish and giant trees towering over blue water cutting through vast log jams and whitewater canyons of moss and ferns where you can see herds of elk, families of otters and eagles stealing fish from the osprey.

Putting engineered log jams in the Hoh River is the environmental equivalent of dumping garbage in the Grand Canyon.

Don’t worry, the Jefferson County road crew will fix the Upper Hoh Road in two weeks.

They’re a highball outfit with big rocks.

_________

Pat Neal is a Hoh River fishing and rafting guide and “wilderness gossip columnist” whose column appears here every Wednesday.

He can be reached at 360-683-9867 or by email via patnealwild life@gmail.com.

More in Opinion

PAT NEAL: Yes, Virginia, there is a steelhead

(With apologies to Francis Pharcellus Church, Editor of the New York Sun,… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: A Christmas survival guide

WHY CAN’T CHRISTMAS last all year? You’d better be glad that it… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: A Dirty Thirties Thanksgiving

THIS IS A story about Thanksgiving in the olden days. It was… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: Hunting season excuses

AND SO, ANOTHER hunting season passes astern. I hope yours went better… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: Spawned-out salmon important to ecosystem

IT WAS DAYLIGHT on the river. The shadowy forms of overhanging trees… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The day after the election

THERE’S NOTHING QUITE like tent camping in the rain forest during the… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The Halloween hunt for Bigfoot

THERE’S NOTHING LIKE a hard day’s writing to make me glad I’m… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: Predicting the coming winter

IT WAS ANOTHER tough week in the news. The National Oceanic and… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The autumn menu

AUTUMN IS A time of plenty on the Olympic Peninsula. The salmon… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: It’s apple picking time

IT WAS DAYLIGHT at the homestead, but I was more than a… Continue reading

Marc Abshire
POINT OF VIEW: Vote yes on both PASD propositions

MUCH IS AT stake in the upcoming elections. In Clallam County, which… Continue reading

PAT NEAL: The composting chronicles

IT MIGHT HAVE been the American philosopher Ralph Waldo Emerson who was… Continue reading